The Necessity of Appearance of Age
One of the arguments that young earth creationists/Biblical chronology proponents regularly employ is that the Cosmos was created with the appearance of age. That is, the world was made X number of years ago, and at its creation it was made to appear much older than it actually is.
A common reply to this argument is that such a scenario would be deceptive. Why would God intentionally deceive us by creating a world that looked as if it were much older than it is?
The problem is that these questions are generally asked rhetorically. Those who ask them don’t want an answer. They view the question as prima facie evidence against the argument for the appearance of age. It works like this:
a.) Creating a world that looks old but is actually young is deceptive.
b.) God is not a deceiver.
c.) : . The world was not created with the appearance of age.
I find this strategy to be rather profoundly lacking. First, it leaves out one of the fundamental steps in the logical process (from the perspective of young earth guys). Continue Reading…